Home

About

Contacts


Papers

Author

Area

Search


AAP Home

SCWP

 

Authors: Baier, Annette C.


Baier, Annette C. (2008). Can Philosophers Be Patriots? New Literary History 39 (1): 121- 135

Area: Social and Political Philosophy
Kw: climatic changes; international relations; terrorism

An essay is presented that analyzes climate change, and violence from disaffected groups, in the context of social philosophy. The author examines the role the United States has played in both of the categories focused on. The author also examines the role her home country of New Zealand has played. Some of the philosophers mentioned in the article include David Hume and Richard Rorty.


Baier, Annette C. (2004). Demoralization, Trust, and the Virtues. In Setting the Moral Compass: Essays by Women Philosophers Cheshire Calhoun (ed.); Oxford: Oxford University Press: pp. 176

Area: Ethics
Kw: morality; trust; virtue

Demoralization is taken to involve temporary loss of virtues previously possessed, and all virtues are taken to be, in their essence, contributors to a decent climate of trust. An account is given of what sort of contribution different virtues make, and a special role is found for the old "theological" virtues of faith, hope, and love, in warding off demoralization in bad times.


Baier, Annette C. (1995). Moral Sentiments, and the Difference They Make, I. Aristotelian Society: Supplementary Volume, Supp(69): 15-30

Area: Ethics
Kw: judgement; morals sentiment; sympathy; virtue

Hume's understanding of our moral sentiments is compared with that of Adam Smith, as well as of Locke, Shaflerburg, and Hutcheson. For Hume these sentiments express our reflective taste in "characters," or character traits. The problems that arise when such tastes differ, between individuals and between cultures, are discussed.


Baier, Annette C. (1995). A Note on Justice, Care, and Immigration Policy. Hypatia 10 (2): 150- 152

Area: Social and Political Philosophy
Kw: immigration; emigration; United States

Focuses on the need to implement a balanced immigration policy in the United States. Special claims of neighboring would-be immigrants; Need for the accommodation of the claims of more distant applicants for citizenship.


Baier, Annette C. (1993). How Can Individualists Share Responsibility? Political Theory 21 (2):228- 248

Area: Social and Political Philosophy
Kw: individual autonomy; individual responsibility; Kant; society

Discusses theoretical propositions, particularly those of Immanuel Kant, on the proper balancing between fostering respect for individual autonomy and taking individual responsibility for society. Kantian individualism and his `categorical imperative' formulation; Alexis de Tocqueville's criticism of American individualism; Status of women, servants and unpropertied persons.


Baier, Annette C. (1993). Moralism and Cruelty: Reflections on Hume and Kant. Ethics 103 (3): 436- 457

Area: Ethics
Kw: criticism; Hume; Kant

Examines morality and cruelty in the context of Immanuel Kant's and David Hume's opposing views. Exploration of what is being relied upon to pressure people into conformity to enlightened morality; Moral standards advocated by the two philosophers; Relative cruelty of both philosophers' versions of morality and its sanctions; Guilt morality versus shame morality.


Baier, Annette C. (1992). Some Virtues of Resident Alienation. Nomos: Yearbook of the American Society for Political and Legal Philosophy 34: 291-308

Area: Social and Political Philosophy
Kw: citizen; ethics; nation; Social Philosophy; virtue

If one is, perhaps for work-related reasons, a resident alien, is one condemned to being a non-political animal? Should one keep to oneself any criticisms one has of one's country of residence? Resident aliens, as aliens know some other country. As residents, they know this one. They are in a good position to make some informed political comparisons. Like field anthropologists and naturalized citizens, their inside knowledge of more than one culture gives them a political perspective which can usefully supplement that of native residents. Might they not be spies for their native land? Smart spies would choose better cover than that of resident aliens, who are comparatively closely monitored.


Baier, Annette C. (1992). Trusting People. Philosophical Perspectives 6:137-153

Area: Ethics
Kw: God; trust

What difference does the design of a social role make to the appropriateness of trusting the person who occupies that role? We may sometimes trust another just because her face reassures us, but usually social role and institutional setting play an important part in creating the conditions in which trust is reasonably given, and successfully sustained.


Baier, Annette C. (1991). MacIntyre on Hume. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 51: 159- 163

Area: Ethics
Kw: judgement

MacIntyre's treatment of Hume's ethics, in Whose Justice, Which Rationality? is praised for its rich textual basis, and criticised for its over-emphasis on Hume's endorsement of early capitalist forms of life, what MacIntyre calls his "anglicising subversion" of Scottish culture. Hume was cosmopolitan more than "anglophile," as were many other Scots in the eighteenth century.


Baier, Annette C. (1991). Whom can Women Trust? In Feminist Ethics, Card, Claudia (ed.) Lawrence: University Press of Kansas.

Area: Philosophy of Gender
Kw: trust; women

The main questions addressed are whether women can trust women more justifiably than they can trust men, and in particular whether and when daughters should trust their mothers. The work of Nancy Chodorow, on "the reproduction of mothering," and of Francine du Plessix Gray, on women-women and mother-daughter relations in the Soviet Union, are discussed. The conclusions drawn are guarded, but not pessimistic.


Baier, Annette C. (1990). Natural Virtues, Natural Vices. Social Philosophy and Policy 1: 24- 34

Area: Ethics
Kw: Hume;  human nature; sentiment; vice; virtue

Hume's writings have been invoked both by sociobiologists who wish to draw normative conclusions from facts about human nature and its capacities for cooperation, and also by their critics, who point to Hume's warnings about the apparent impossibility of deducing an "ought" from an "is." He does make facts about what is normal in human populations highly relevant to what it is reasonable of us to take as moral standards, but the step from such facts to normative endorsement takes complicated footwork. Our nature has multiple potential, and ambivalence, especially concerning our proven sexist and racist tendencies, is part of that nature.


Baier, Annette C. (1990). What Emotions are about. Philosophical Perspectives 4 :1-29.

Area: Philosophy of Mind
Kw: intentionality; emotions; expression; phenomenology

Discusses the interrelations between the aspects of human emotions. Intentionality; Expressivity; Moral significance; Kinds of philosophical views of emotions; Cognitivists; Emotivists; Moral phenomenologism of Annette Baier; Efforts of Baier to avoid the reductionism of cognitivists and emotivists; Attention to Baier's notion of deep objects of emotions; Account of the expressivity of emotions; Implications for the understanding of the role of emotions in moral lives.


Baier, Annette C. (1988). Pilgrim’s Progress. Canadian Journal of Philosophy 18: 315- 330

Area: Social and Political Philosophy
Kw: contractarianism; freedom; liberty; moral code

Gauthier's "morals by agreement" is criticised as failing to provide a basis for any moral duties to helpless children and others who pose no threat and have no bargaining chips. Incoherences are found in his account of basic rights.


Baier, Annette C. (1987). Commodious Living. Synthese: An International Journal for Epistemology  72 (2): 157- 185

Area: Epistemology
Kw: ethics; honor; human nature; social ethics

Hobbes takes the true morality to consist in obedience to dictates of reason that secure peace and commodious living. One of these, the fifth, requires 'compleasance,' (sic) or mutual accommodation, and he says those who keep it are the 'commodi'. Commodious or sociable living is part of the moral goal, and sociability part of the necessary means. Reason, for Hobbes, itself depends upon speech and the mutual accommodation involved in that "noblest invention of all other." The dictates of reason do not initiate human sociability, but presuppose and protect it.


Baier, Annette C. (1986). Trust and Antitrust. Ethics 96 (2) 231- 260

Area: Ethics
Kw: contract; morality; value; power; trust

Trust is of central moral importance, both as a great good, and as the prior condition of the evils of betrayal and conspiracy. Our tradition in moral philosophy has offered no general account of when we should trust, and meet trust. The attention given to contractual agreement, in that tradition, is attention to one form of trust--that between more or less equals, once they have voluntarily become mutual trusters, on a limited matter for a limited time. A more general account is offered, and a moral test for trust-relationships.


Baier, Annette C. (1986). Extending the Limits of Moral Theory. Journal of Philosophy 83: 538-544

Area: Ethics
Kw: belief; limits; morality; Hume

A moral theory is usually the outcome of a single individual's ruminations about what version of morality merits our support--a web of arguments appealing to our intellects. Morality itself is a social product--a set of customs and standards for evaluating laws, customs, characters. A moral theory would be less limited if like its subject matter it were a cooperative product, and appealed to heart and guts as well as intellect and self-interest.


Baier, Annette C. (1985). What do Women Want in a Moral Theory?’ Nous 19 (1): 53- 63

Area: Ethics
Kw: women

Different from men's, then one would expect women's moral philosophy also to exhibit different emphases, as indeed it has. That work, so far, contains little "theory." is moral theory a male product, the wish for theory tied to male moral prejudices? Could any moral theory systematize and extend the intuitions of both women and men? It would need to contain an account both of obligation and of the ethics of love and care. A theory taking the concepts of proper trust and proper response to trust to be central might accomplish this double task.


Baier, Annette C. (1984). Some Thoughts on how we Moral Philosophers live now. Monist: An International Quarterly Journal of General Philosophical Inquiry 67: 490-497

Area: Ethics
Kw: moral reasoning; philosophizing; Social Philosophy; social structure

Moral philosophers do "theory," or "apply" someone else's theory, helped by their own intuitions, to decisions others have to take. We advise other professions on their professional ethics. If really reflective, we should reflect on our social niche. Should a society pay so many of us to do what we do? We should improve our own professional ethics before advising others on theirs.


Baier, Annette C. (1981). Frankena and Hume on Points of View. Monist: An International Quarterly Journal of General Philosophical Inquiry 64: 342-358

Area: Ethics
Kw: caring; practical reason; sentiment; sympathy

Frankena's treatment of the moral point of view as the source of less final practical judgments than those made by practical reason, simply as such, is compared with hume's version of the moral point of view. The role of sympathy, the claimed relation of morality to ultimate rationality, the reducibility of point-of-view talk to other locutions, is investigated in the two philosophers' accounts of morality. More disagreements than agreements are found between the two, despite the shared locution of the "moral point of view".


Baier, Annette C. (1981). Cartesian Persons.  Philosophia: Philosophical Quarterly of Israe10 (3-4): 169- 188

Area: Metaphysics
Kw: consciousness; person

The dualism which strawson attributes to descartes is only half of descartes' total view, since he has a different account of how we should conceive of ourselves when what we are doing is seeking the good, rather than searching for metaphysical truth. Behind the metaphysical dualism lies the methodological dualism of theory and practice, thought and action. Descartes' and strawson's accounts of persons and of consciousness are compared, and second person psychological claims are found to be as important as first and third person claims.


Baier, Annette C. (1980). Hume on Resentment. Hume Studies 6: 133- 149

Area: Ethics
Kw: justice; pride; resentment; Social Philosophy

Hume says that to be a right-holder, a party to conventions of justice, one must have power to make resentment felt. The relation of resentment, for hume an instinctive passion, to the "irregular" passion of envy and the "mixed" passion of respect is explored, and the role of the concepts of power and social status in hume's philosophy highlighted. As instinctive benevolence is the attendant protector of the indirect passion of love, so resentment is the watchdog attendant of pride. Pride, since it is always pride in possession, is essentially pride in power. Both resentment, and each proud person's need for the esteem of others, generates a humean dynamic (foreshadowing the hegelian dialectic) whereby, given the postulated psychology, moral equilibrium can come out of conflict.


Baier, Annette C. (1980). Rights of Past and Future Generations. In Responsibilities to Future Generations, Partridge, E. (ed.) Prometheus Books, Buffalo, NY: 171- 183

Area: Ethics
Kw: community; future; obligation; right

Past persons are believed to have rights, for example the right to have their properly made private wills executed. We recognize present persons as spokesmen for past persons, claiming their rights. We could appoint present persons as spokesmen for the general human rights of future persons without conceptual or moral incoherence. Indeed our obligations to past persons includes the obligation to pass on to future generations those transmitted goods, such as constitutions, and also unpoisoned water and air, which we inherited from past persons. In as a far as past persons made efforts to create or preserve, and to pass on, such goods, it was not to pass them on only to us, but to an indefinite run of generations. Our obligations to past and to future persons reinforce one another.


Baier, Annette C. (1979). Good Men’s Women: Hume on Chastity and Trust. Hume Studies 5: 1- 19

Area: Ethics
Kw: chastity; marriage; trust; virtue; woman

Hume concludes his discussion of artificial virtues with a section on modesty and chastity, which provide, he says, still more conspicuous instances of artifice. It is argued, on the contrary, that chastity is an atypical humean artificial virtue in several respects. It is an artificial virtue in women whose point, on hume's account, is to make paternity determinable and so make possible the natural male virtue of parental affection. What is more, its utility depends not on universal practice in the female sex, but on each single woman's exceptionless practice. Indeed, hume assumes that not all women will aspire to the status of mothers of children of recognized lineage. Both the chastity of respectable women and the greater liberty of males depends upon the existence of women whose social "virtues" will be the absence of chastity and modesty. In all these respects hume's account of chastity raises general theoretical questions about the nature, scope, and utility of all hume's social artifices.


Baier, Annette C. (1976). Realizing What’s What. Philosophical Quarterly 26 (105): 328- 337

Area: Ethics
Kw: Hume

Four features of "realize" distinguish it from "know" and show realization to be of epistemological interest. "realize" rejects a "whether"-complement, and the accusative and infinitive construction. These indicate a loose link between realizing and prior question-raising. Not "know", as vendler claimed, but "realize" lacks interrogative flavor. The limited use for 'i do not realize...' and the deviance of 'you, but not i, realize...' indicate that realization, unlike knowledge, cannot be recognized without being shared.


Baier, Annette C. (1970). Act and Intent. Journal of Philosophy 67 (19): 648- 658

Area: Ethics
Kw: action; intention; object

Several features of chisholm's analysis of intention are cited to show that his attempt to analyze intention without relying on the concept of action is unsatisfactory. These include a too narrowly causal account of the means end relation involved in purposive action, a failure to exclude intentions to do the impossible, a failure to distinguish competent intentional action from lucky wish fulfillment, or intention to do from consent to another's act. It is claimed that the proper objects of intention are acts, not states of affairs.


Supported by the AAP Standing Commitee for Women in the Profession

Thanks to the Australasian Association of Philosophy and Macquarie University.