Home

About

Contacts


Papers

Author

Area

Search


AAP Home

SCWP

 

Authors: Card, Claudia


Card, C. (2007). Recognizing Terrorism. Journal of Ethics 11 (1): 1- 29

Area: Social and Political Philosophy
Kw: Terrorism

It has been claimed that most of the world’s preventable suffering and death are caused not by terrorism but by poverty. That claim, if true, could be hard to substantiate. For most terrorism is not publicly recognized as such, and it is far commoner than paradigms of the usual suspects suggest. Everyday lives under oppressive regimes, in racist environments, and of women, children, and elders everywhere who suffer violence in their homes offer instances of terrorisms that seldom capture public attention. Or so this essay argues, through exploring two models of terrorism and the points of view highlighted by each.

Card, C. (2007). Gay Divorce: Thoughts on the Legal Regulation of Marriage. Hypatia 22 (1): 24- 38

Area: Social and Political Philosophy
Kw: Marriage; intimate relationships; partnerships; domestic violence

Although the exclusion of LGBTs from the rites and rights of marriage is arbitrary and unjust, the legal institution of marriage is itself so riddled with injustice that it would be better to create alternative forms of durable intimate partnership that do not invoke the power of the state. Card's essay develops a case for this position, taking up an injustice sufficiently serious to constitute an evil: the sheltering of domestic violence.


Card, C. (2006). The L Word and the F Word. Hypatia 21 (2): 223- 229

Area: Philosophy of Gender
Kw: Language; feminism


In the jargon of today's mainstream mass media, 'liberal' has become the L word and 'feminist' has become the F word. This co-opting of L and F trades on public squeamishness regarding the designations of earlier, and blunter, L and F words. 'Liberal' and 'feminist' are being shooed toward closets formerly inhabited by 'lesbian' and 'fuck'--words that liberals (in the case of 'fuck') and feminists (in the case of 'lesbian') worked so enthusiastically to bring out of the closet in the second half of the twentieth century. What an interesting reversal, this move to closet the outers! Revenge, perhaps? An aspect of the revenge: closeting them together? 'Liberal' and 'feminist' often sit uneasily in proximity to one another. Yet in the current reactionary political climate, uneasiness regarding 'liberal' should be problematic for feminists. Readers of this journal need no prodding to resist the closeting of 'feminist.' About 'liberal,' the case is less clear. 'Liberal' receives a load of flack from the political left as well as from the right. Feminist philosophers have contributed substantial flack from the left. Closets are a foreseeable outcome of the creation of a derogatory, scornful aura around a concept, investing it with an emotive load that can easily embarrass any who might find the concept applicable to themselves. (First Paragraph)


Card, C. and Marsoobian, A. T. (2006). Introduction: Genocide’s Aftermath. Metaphilosophy 37 (3- 4): 229- 307

Area: Ethics
Kw: Genocide; reparation; responsibility

Abstract not available


Card, C. (2004). Environmental Atrocities and Non- Sentient Life. Ethics and the Environment 9 (1): 23- 45

Area: Ethics
Kw: Atrocity; environmental ethics; evil; tree

Abstract not available


Card, C. (2003). The Cambridge Companion to Simone de Beauvoir. Cambridge University Press

Area: Continental Philosophy
Kw: Existentialism; sexuality; feminist theory

Simone de Beauvoir was a philosopher and writer of notable range and influence whose work is central to feminist theory, French existentialism, and contemporary moral and social philosophy. The essays in this volume examine the major aspects of her thought. They explore her views on the role of biology, sexuality and sexual difference, and evil; the influence on her work of Heidegger, Sartre, Merleau-Ponty, Husserl, and others; and the philosophical significance of her memoirs and fiction.


Card, C. (2003). Genocide and Social Death. Hypatia 18 (1): 63- 79

Area: Social and Political Philosophy
Kw: Genocide

Social death, central to the evil of genocide (whether the genocide is homicidal or primarily cultural), distinguishes genocide from other mass murders. Loss of social vitality is loss of identity and thereby of meaning for one's existence. Seeing social death at the center of genocide takes our focus off body counts and loss of individual talents, directing us instead to mourn losses of relationships that create community and give meaning to the development of talents.

Card, C. (2003). Questions Regarding a War on Terrorism. Hypatia 18 (1): 164- 169

Area: Social and Political Philosophy
Terrorism

The concept of a war on terrorism creates havoc with attempts to apply rules of war. For "terrorism" is not an agent. Nor is it clear what relationship to terrorism agents must have in order to be legitimate targets. Nor is it clear what kinds of terrorism count. Would a war on terrorism in the home be a justifiable response to domestic battering? If not, do similar objections apply to a war on public terrorism?

Card, C. (2002). Responsibility Ethics, Shared Understandings, and Moral Communities. Hypatia 17 (1): 141- 155

Area: Ethics
Kw: Community; moral theory; responsibility

Margaret Walker's Moral Understandings offers an "expressive-collaborative," culturally situated, practice-based picture of morality, critical of a "theoretical-juridical" picture in most prefeminist moral philosophy since Henry Sidgwick. This essay compares her approach to ethics with that of John Rawls, another exemplar of the "theoretical-juridical" model, and asks how Walker's approach would apply to several ethical issues, including interaction with (other) animals, social reform and revolution, and basic human rights.

Card, C. (2003). What’s Wrong with Adult- Child Sex? Journal of Social Philosophy 33 (2): 170- 177

Area: Social and Political Philosophy
Kw: Pedophilia; children; sex

Abstract not availavble


Card, C. (2000). Women, Evil, and Grey Zones. Metaphilosophy 31 (5): 509- 528

Area: Social and Political Philosophy
Kw: Evil; ethics; Primo Levi; Stockholm Syndrome; women; character; feminism; oppression; Patricia Hearst; slavery

Gray zones, which develop wherever oppression is severe and lasting, are inhabited by victims of evil who become complicit in perpetrating on others the evils that threaten to engulf themselves. Women, who have inhabited many gray zones, present challenges for feminist theorists, who have long struggled with how resistance is possible under coercive institutions. Building on Primo Levi's reflections on the gray zone in Nazi death camps and ghettos, this essay argues that resistance is sometimes possible, although outsiders are rarely, if ever, in a position to judge when. It also raises questions about the adequacy of ordinary moral concepts to mark the distinctions that would be helpful for thinking about how to respond in a gray zone.

Card, C. (1998) Evils and Inequalities. Journal of Contemporary Legal Issues 87

Area: Social and Political Philosophy
Inequality; feminism; evil


In this paper I defend the view that opposition to inequalities is less essential to feminism than opposition to evils, and that it is not fruitful to try to recast the concern to address evils as a concern with fundamental equality. My position is not that inequalities are unimportant, but that when it comes to prioritizing, evils are more important.


Card, C. (1999). The Road to Lake Wobegon. Journal of Social Philosophy 30 (3): 369- 378

Area: Philosophy of Gender
Kw: Ethics; justice; law; morality

James Sterba's book 'Justice for Here and Now' applies a peace-making approach to many contemporary controversies in social justice, including issues of feminism and homosexuality. He argues for family and workplace restructuring as means to enabling women and men alike to develop all the virtues of good human beings. An alternative to Sterba's strategy, perhaps more likely to achieve that end, questions the practice of heterosexual cohabitation and encourages same sex households. This essay develops and defends that alternative.

Card, C. (1998). Stoicism, Evil, and the Possibility of Morality. (1998). Metaphilosophy 29 (4): 245- 253

Area: Ethics
Kw: Stoicism; moral luck; social and interpersonal ethics

Martha Nussbaum's work has been characterized by a sustained critique of Stoic ethics, insofar as that ethics denies the validity and importance of our valuing things that elude our control. This essay explores the idea that the very possibility of morality, understood as social or interpersonal ethics, presupposes that we do value such things. If my argument is right, Stoic ethics is unable to recognize the validity of morality (so understood) but can at most acknowledge duties to oneself. A further implication is that moral luck, so far from undermining morality as some have held, is presupposed by the very possibility of morality.

Card, C. (1998). Radicalesbianfeminist Theory. Hypatia 13 (1): 206- 213

Area: Philosophy of Gender
Kw: Lesbian oppression; women; sexism; women’s liberation

Cheshire Calhoun has been working to distinguish lesbian oppression from the sexist oppression of women in general, with the idea that different strategies may be needed to oppose each. On a radical feminist understanding of sexism, however, lesbian oppression is a very important part of the oppression of females generally. Women's liberation requires opposition to lesbian oppression. Or so I argue in supporting radicalesbianfeminism as a unified theory.

Card, C. (1996). Rape as a Weapon of War. Hypatia 11 (4): 5- 18

Area: Social and Political Philosophy
Kw: War; rape; women; girls; torture; terrorism

This essay examines how rape of women and girls by male soldiers works as a martial weapon. Continuities with other torture and terrorism and with civilian rape are suggested. The inadequacy of past philosophical treatments of the enslavement of war captives is briefly discussed. Social strategies are suggested for responding and a concluding fantasy offered, not entirely social, of a strategy to change the meanings of rape to undermine its use as a martial weapon.

Card, C. (1996). Against Marriage and Motherhood. Hypatia 11 (3): 1- 23

Area: Philosophy of Gender
Kw: Lesbian and gay rights; parenthood; marriage; intimate unions

This essay argues that current advocacy of lesbian and gay rights to legal marriage and parenthood insufficiently criticizes both marriage and motherhood as they are currently practiced and structured by Northern legal institutions. Instead we would do better not to let the State define our intimate unions and parenting would be improved if the power presently concentrated in the hands of one or two guardians were diluted and distributed through an appropriately concerned community.


Card, C. (1996). The Unnatural Lottery: Character and Moral Luck. Temple University Press

Area: Ethics
Character development; good person; virtues

The opportunities to become a good person are not the same for everyone. Modern European ethical theory, especially Kantian ethics, assumes the same virtues are accessible to all who are capable of rational choice. Character development, however, is affected by circumstances, such as those of wealth and socially constructed categories of gender, race, and sexual orientation, which introduce factors beyond the control of individuals. Implications of these influences for morality have, since the work of Williams and Nagel in the seventies, raised questions in philosophy about the concept of moral luck. In The Unnatural Lottery, Claudia Card examines how luck enters into moral character and considers how some of those who are oppressed can develop responsibility. Luck is often best appreciated by those who have known relatively bad luck and have been unable to escape steady comparison of their lot with those of others. The author takes as her paradigms the luck of middle and lower classes of women who face violence and exploitation, of lesbians who face continuing pressure to hide or self-destruct, of culturally Christian whites who have ethnic privilege, and of adult survivors of child abuse. How have such people been affected by luck in who they are and can become, the good lives available to them, the evils they may be liable to embody? Other philosophers have explored the luck of those who begin from privileged positions and then suffer reversals of fortune. Claudia Card focuses on the more common cases of those who begin from socially disadvantaged positions, and she considers some who find their good luck troubling when its source is the unnatural lottery of social injustice. (book overview)


Card, C. (1994). The Military ban and the ROTC: A Study in Closeting. Journal of Homosexuality 27 (3- 4): 117- 46

Area: Philosophy of Gender
Kw: Lesbian and gay; discrimination; military; exclusion

This article examines reasons for university involvement in protesting ROTC policies discriminatory toward lesbians and gay men. The formal exclusion of lesbians and gay men from the military permits not only the abuses in selective enforcement of the policy and considerable economic costs to maintain it, but also contributes to the perpetuation of the closet. Closeting is not a phenomenon chosen by lesbians and gay men for reasons of their own, and it rewards deceit, penalizes honesty, blames lesbians and gays for the mistrust of others, and effects a psychological division ("doubling") of individual identity and corrupts individual responsibility. For these reasons, university educators, as committed to the advance of truth, have an obligation to protest ROTC compliance with discriminatory policies.


Card, C. (1991). Removing Veils of Ignorance. Noûs 25 (2): 194- 196

Area: Social and Political Philosophy
Kw: Cultural pluralism; racism; sexism; class oppression; women

The present state of philosophical consciousness of histories of racism, sexism, and class oppression indicate a need to remove veils of ignorance rather than to don them. Two trends reflecting sensitivity to this need are 'holism' and 'particularism' in recent philosophy by women and others who do not necessarily trace their intellectual heritages to men of ancient Greece. These trends and their interrelationships are examined and defended.

Card, C. (1990). Why Homophobia? Hypatia 5 (3): 110- 117

Area: Philosophy of Gender
Kw: Homophobia; pride; shame

Suzanne Pharr's Homophobia: A Weapon of Sexism may be an effective tool for women committed to overcoming their own homophobia who want practical advice on recognizing and eradicating it, although as an essay in theory it does not advance the issues. The author seems unaware that Celia Kitzinger has argued recently that "homophobia" is not a helpful concept because it individualizes problems better seen as political and begs the question of the rationality of the fear. I argue that "homophobia" has been misused but that freed of the medical model and understood in connection with issues of pride and shame, it can be a helpful concept.

Card, C. (1990). Caring and Evil. Hypatia 5 (1): 101- 108

Area: Ethics
Kw: Ethics of care; ethical relationships; abuse

Nel Noddings, in Caring: A Feminine Approach to Ethics and Moral Education (1984), presents and develops an ethic of care as an alternative to an ethic that treats justice as a bask concept. I argue that this care ethic is unable to give an adequate account of ethical relationships between strangers and that it is also in danger of valorizing relationships in which carers are seriously abused.

Card, C. (1990). Pluralist Lesbian Separatism. In Lesbian Philosophies and Cultures; Jennifer Allen (ed.); SUNY Press: 125- 142

Area: Philosophy of Gender
Kw: Lesbian Philosophy

Abstract not available


Card, C. (1988). Gratitude and Obligation. American Philosophical Quarterly 25 (2): 115 – 127

Area: Ethics
Kw: Friendship; formal and informal obligations

The ethics of friendship requires clarification of the relationships between gratitude and obligation. The paradox in the idea of a debt of gratitude is unraveled by means of a distinction between two paradigms of obligation: the debtor paradigm and the trustee paradigm. Kant's and Aristotle's views on the obligations incurred to a benefactor are rejected in favor of Hobbes's on the ground that only Hobbes's account remains congruent with the spirit of gratitude. The trustee model of obligation is then used to clarify misplaced gratitude, especially in relationships of unequal power.


Card, C. (1972). On Mercy. Philosophical Review 81 (2): 182- 207

Area: Ethics
Kw: Benevolence; charity; ethics; justice; mercy; retribution; right

Abstract not available


Thanks to the Australasian Association of Philosophy and Macquarie University.